"Doubt and belief are ultimately equivalent. Doubt relies on an alternate subterranean set of tacit belief in something else. Those who say otherwise are unaware of the alternative beliefs they hold to live." - Tim Keller (as ascribed by his son and fellow Presbyterian Church In America minister Michael Keller ) *** Everybody carries what (Lutheran-background) sociologist Peter L. Berger calls a " plausibility structure " in their mind - a set of deep assumptions about what is credible and in-credible, believable and unbelievable. It functions the same way as Christian doctrine and discipleship. Everyone believes something - a set of 'doctrines,' foundational first-principle concepts about the nature of reality, including: The existence or non-existence of the supernatural realm; The nature of ourselves (pleasure-seeking biological machines? Carbon-based relatively intelligent bipeds? Images of God?) ; The nature of other people, (aliens? Stran...
Contemporary wealth and technological development have normalised secular self-gratification in the "developed" "Western" world. We expect a life of ease, where the only difficulty is choosing which new pleasure to pursue next. As Matt Fraser says over at The Gospel Coalition Canada , this makes it difficult for us to believe what "many other Christians through the ages" took for granted, and what many "around the world" still experience today: "following Jesus is painful." I think this expectation of ease is a socio-cultural, not a uniquely "religious" or "theological," issue. For most of human history, life has been difficult. Most religions invest religious effort with value - doing good makes you worthy to be "saved" (whatever "salvation" means within that religion - nirvana [Hindu and Buddhist], Jannah [Islam], less time in purgatory [Roman Catholic], etc). It's no surprise that we'...