Skip to main content

Justin Moffatt: Beyond the Predictable Church & Sermon Talk 1

I’m at our Moore year reunion houseparty. Our speaker’s Justin Moffatt, from York St Anglican church in downtown Sydney. I’m blogging almost live – Justin just finished his first talk, I took notes on my laptop, I just tidied them up a bit, asked Justin for permission to blog – and here it is.

The case for predictability
A metronome is predictable. But it gives the piano player a structure to start singing a tune.
The word of God and the gospel of Christ is the metronome that structures everything we do. It enables us to sing a song to our congregation, and encourage them to join us in singing the song of the Christ who died for us. We aim to aid the congregation to sing this song.
God never changes. We have one story that will never change. We tell that gospel that Christ is Lord to a world that has a different story. We must preach that one gospel.
Jonah is about God’s consistency, and how frustrating Jonah finds that consistency. God is consistently and stubbornly good; Jonah if people repent, God is always consistently kind.
Acts 20:20-35: Paul consistently spoke the same message. So our task is to constantly speak the whole counsel of God.
1 Cor 1: Paul is predictable in his message – the cross – and his method – cruciform.
The congregation needs to be confident that the gospel will be preached each week. That’s the only way the regulars will be confident to bring friends.
The congregation needs to lose all dependence on your giftedness. Otherwise they’ll put their faith in you, not Christ.
If the passage is saying something different from what the preacher’s saying, there’s something wrong. The preacher needs to say what the passage is saying.
We preachers need to be freed from the tyranny of performance.

Beyond predictability
God’s grace is always surprising.
Hab 1:5 Habakkuk complains about sin in Judah. And God says he’s going to do something that you wouldn’t believe even if I told you.
Jesus spoke in unpredictable ways.
Matt 20 the parable of the generous landowner: the punch-line is about God’s grace.
Luke 16 parable of the shrewd manager. A crook held up as a model? Why would Jesus do that?
There’s only one place where Jesus is predictable: Mark 12: “What is the greatest commandment” – “Love God and neighbour” – “well done, teacher”. Outside of that, Jesus is unpredictable.
The human heart is deceitful; therefore the gospel will always be a surprise.
Pastorally, our leaders need a fresh aspect on the gospel. We have an old story, but we need to sing it in a new way.
Our listeners need both gravitas and levitas – weight and lightness, seriousness and freshness, challenge and humour, sobriety and joy, explanation and poetry, information (theology) and insight (particular lives of our people).
The congregation needs us to be ourselves, not someone else. If we try to be someone else, we’ll be predictable. We’re not Mark Driscoll or Tim Keller! The Spirit works in us & puts his stamp on us in particular!
Labels:

Comments

Justin said…
Nice work, Kamal.
14 April 2009 at 17:50
Roger Gallagher said…
Please give my regards to everyone.
14 April 2009 at 23:21
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A better understanding of nonbelief

The Nones Project is an ongoing study into the belief systems of people who call themselves non-religious. A few weeks ago one of the project leaders,  Ryan Burge  of Washington University,  posted some really interesting preliminary results  on his Substack.  1. We've probably heard of people who are spiritual but not religious (SBNRs). SBNRs were "the largest group of nones" in the sample. They believe in the supernatural realm but not necessarily in "a God." They are "deeply skeptical of religion but highly interested in spirituality," therefore individualistic and anti-institutional.  2. But this study differentiated SBNRs from people they called Nones In Name Only, NiNos. They different to SBNRs by being religious about their spiritual. They believe not just in the supernatural but in "God." And they tend to engage in traditional communal religious practices while SBNRs practice individualised eclectic bespoke spiritual practices. The s...
Post a Comment
Read more

The different distractions of secularity and spirituality

There has been a lot of discussion about the recent 'vibe shift' away from radical atheism back towards an openness to the supernatural. I don't think this new spirituality is necessarily an openness to the unique claims of Christ. It will more probably replace one set of commonly-accepted misunderstandings about Jesus with another.  Under radical atheism, people dismissed the Biblical claims about Jesus' resurrection because they 'knew' that it was impossible. Jesus hadn't really died. He just passed out (after being beaten and whipped and crucified) and then woke up in the tomb (and rolled away the stone himself and overcame several guards). Or the disciples hallucinated that they saw him (even though Jewish beliefs of the time didn't expect one person to rise possessing eternal life himself; they expected a general resurrection at the end of time - see John 11:24 ). Or something else.  The so-called 'explanations' of Jesus' non-resurrectio...
Post a Comment
Read more
TGC Australia recently published an analysis by Dr Sarah Quicke of whether we are experiencing a 'quiet revival' of interest in and/or conversion to Christianity  here in Australia. It does it a good job of describing the difficulties involved in both gathering and interpreting data about religious beliefs and behaviours, e.g. the difference between the 44% who (still) call themselves Christian and the 8% of people aged 18-35 who actually "believed and lived out the gospel."  Quicke refers to the very insightful McCrindle report An Undercurrent Of Faith , released in March 2025, which uses an analytical method called cohort analysis to try and work out how a particular group of people tend to behave over time. The purpose of this post is to draw attention to one element of that report which agrees with Quicke's analysis but also adds some detail to it.  Here is what the cohort analysis showed about different age groups' identification with Christianity:  As y...
Post a Comment
Read more